A free four-player murder mystery you can print tonight
The Wet Half-Hour. Four suspects, eleven printed case documents, forty-five minutes at a kitchen table. Nobody acts, nobody lies, and nobody knows who did it — including whoever did it.
The Juniper Inn, Wren's Hollow, a wet Tuesday afternoon in November. A debt collector called Edmund Rook goes down to the cellar at five past four to count the stock that secures the note on the inn. At eight minutes to five the coal merchant tips a sack down the chute, comes round to the hatch steps and finds him at the bottom of them with the door-weight beside him and his wallet open.
Four people were in the building or the yard. All four of them are sitting at your table.
Download the game — 21 pages, and the answer is not in it.
The game · US Letter (PDF) The game · A4 (PDF)
Download the sealed answer — a separate file, behind a full-page STOP card. Print it without opening it and put it in an envelope, and whoever printed the game can still play.
What is in it
- Four suspect cards, two to a page with a cut line. Every word on all four is true.
- Eleven case documents: the constable's scene report, the village weather book, the dead man's own list of the papers in his wallet, an inn day book, a press copy of a letter, a telephone exchange ticket, a hotel manager's reply, two household books, a carrier's delivery ticket, the constable's measurements, and his sheet on the yard and the hall stand.
- A one-page guest sheet and a one-page host sheet that contains no spoilers at all, so the person who prints it is not excluded from playing.
- Accusation slips, four to a page, and a shared sheet the table fills in together.
- A separate answer file with the reveal and a page showing exactly how it was proved, chain by chain.
The rules it is built on
These are the same five rules our paid games are built on, and this is the smallest honest demonstration of them we could make:
- Nothing is memorised. A card is a reference sheet you read off when somebody asks you something.
- Nothing is read aloud in character. No accents, no costumes, no acting, anywhere.
- Nobody lies. Every card is literally true. The misdirection comes from omission, refusal and missing context, and "I don't remember" is printed on all four cards as a legal answer.
- Nobody knows they are the culprit, including the culprit. So nobody can give it away and nobody can be blamed for giving it away.
- The paper carries the whole solution. A player who talks to nobody can still solve it by reading. The four of you are the fast route, not the only one — which is why the game does not break if somebody has to leave at half past nine.
How to run it
Print, cut two pages, deal the cards face down. Then three rounds on a timer: the scene (12 minutes), the papers (15), the measurements (10). Everybody writes a secret accusation and names the one fact on paper they would hang it on. Then you open the answer.
It works at four. At three, leave out the doctor's card and read it aloud as a written statement — everything on it is also on a document. At five, the extra person keeps the time and reads out the ending, which is the best job at the table.
Why we are giving away a whole game
Because it is the only honest advertisement for the paid ones. You can read a listing that says "fair play" and "the host can play too" and have no way of knowing whether either is true. Print this, play it, and you will know exactly what we mean by both — including whether our idea of fair matches yours.
There is no email capture here and nothing to sign up for. The PDF is a link on this page.
The Hour Candle, $29 — a Christmas murder mystery for 6 to 12 guests,
90 to 120 minutes, 22 case documents instead of 11, seven suspects and five witnesses, built to the
same five rules.
The Golden Tin, $39 — the same machinery for a room of 16 to 40 at an
office holiday party, with an evidence wall instead of a table.
Until Breakfast, $24.99 — a 24-day murder mystery advent calendar, one
envelope a day from the 1st of December.
The small print
The PDFs are free for personal use: print them as many times as you like, for your own table, your classroom, your office or your book club. Please do not resell them or put them behind a paywall. If something is wrong with a file, the fault is ours and we would like to know.
Read next
- How to host a murder mystery dinner party at home
A timetable, a print plan and the five decisions that make the evening work — including how to host a murder mystery party and still play it yourself.
- How many people do you need for a murder mystery party?
Four can work, 8 to 12 is the sweet spot and above 16 it becomes a different event. What changes at each size, and what breaks at the edge of a game's range.
- What you actually have to print for a murder mystery party (and how to cut it)
The print list, paper and ink, the four printer settings that ruin a printable game, how to cut cards straight, and a one-sheet test that catches everything.